Analysis

Why Opdo moved to three lenses for a fixed-focus thermal camera

The optical engineering startup’s model held focus to within about 5 µm of its room-temperature setting from −40 to +85 °C. Its own tolerance run leaves a question about the corners of the image.
A handheld FLIR E8 thermal imaging camera.

Opdo set out to design a 35.4 mm, F/1 lens for a long-wave infrared camera without a focus motor. It began with a published two-element prescription whose focal length was about 10.8 mm. Scaling that design up in the model increased the focus shift to as much as 101 µm over temperature. The camera’s chosen lens speed therefore set a tight focus budget even as the longer optical system moved further with temperature.

Opdo tried reshaping the two elements and changing their materials. Its account says the optimiser could bring the thermal shift down, but the resulting lens still did not bring the full 8 to 12 µm band to a sufficiently sharp focus. The three-element design sandwiches zinc selenide between two IRG 26 glass elements. The centre element helps correct the difference in focus across wavelengths, while the overall design balances the shift in the lens against the expansion of the aluminium barrel. Focus is initially set with a shim behind the detector.

With the nominal dimensions in the model, Opdo reported a worst-case lens-only modulation transfer function of 0.391 at the centre and 0.229 at the corner, both at 41.7 line pairs per millimetre. That frequency is the sampling limit of the proposed sensor’s 12 µm pixels. In a separate tolerance run, 99% of 500 simulated assemblies stayed above 0.20 at the centre across three temperatures. The 0.20 threshold is below the 0.25 centre target used for the nominal design, and the tolerance result does not cover the corners.

Opdo says its engineers chose the starting design and decided when to move to three elements; its software handled much of the search and optimisation. The case study does not show a lens built and measured across temperature, or establish how often an assembled unit would meet the original centre and corner targets.

Sources: Opdo’s published design study; Published starting lens prescription, US9007683B2.

Continue reading